Mustard Up Horseradish Hot Sauce – Mild 5oz

Nutritonal Panel

$11.99
$11.99

Available on Amazon

Share:

Meet Mustard Up Mild. Real horseradish root, warm mustard seed, and a pinch of turmeric, cooked down from scratch with oven-roasted sweet potatoes, tomatoes, onions, garlic, and a squeeze of lime. It opens with that clean horseradish bite, settles into golden mustard warmth, and finishes with a gentle pepper glow that never overstays its welcome. Made for ballpark franks, soft pretzels, deviled eggs, and the ham sandwich that deserves better.

HEAT LEVEL: 1 out of 5. All flavor, easy warmth. Ready for the full climb? Try Mustard Up Spicy.

THE PEPPERS: Jalapeño, Fresno, Habanero, and Long Hot, grown in our own garden and sourced from local farms.

WHAT’S MISSING: Added salt. Preservatives. Gums and thickeners. Nobody misses them.

THE DETAILS: 5 oz bottle, small batch, made in New Jersey. Refrigerate after opening.

Mustard Up Horseradish Hot Sauce – Mild 5oz
$11.99
$11.99
A bottle of Jersey Grill Mild Hot Sauce stands centered on a red and silver metal tin in a blurred diner setting with red booths in the background.
A bottle of Jersey Girl Mustard Up hot sauce displayed on a rustic wooden surface with food props like tomatoes, garlic, and meat. The left side features a vintage-style informational panel with text about mild heat, sodium-free, real ingredients, and no gums.
A product infographic for 'Mustard Up' hot sauce by 'Jersey Girl' showing the bottle alongside illustrations and photos of the real ingredients: tomatoes, sweet potatoes, jalapeños, habanero, horseradish root, mustard powder, onions, garlic, lime, and spices. The background is a textured beige with a red border.

Flavor Profile

Taste: Horseradish bite and mustard warmth over roasted sweet potatoes and tomatoes, with a gentle glow from four hand-picked peppers.

Aftertaste: Fades warm with a mild pepper burn

Aroma: Like a ballpark on opening day

Attributes

Heat

MildHot

Spice

LightMediumIntense

Horseradish

LowMediumHigh

Body

ThinMediumThick

Details

Heat rating: 1 out of 5.

Size: 5 oz (148 ml).

Pepper blend: Jalapeño, Fresno, Habanero and Long Hot.

Pairs with: Hot dogs, soft pretzels, eggs, brats and ham sandwiches.

Grown local: Peppers from our own garden and local farms.

Nothing else on the shelf tastes like it.

No Added Salt
No Preservatives, Gums or Thickeners
No Artificial Ingredients
Vegan

  • Horseradish Mustard,

    Gently Fired  

    All the old-school horseradish mustard taste with just enough heat to keep it interesting. Gentle, flavorful, and sodium free, it’s the one the whole table reaches for.





    A bottle of Jersey Girl Mild Horseradish Mustard stands on a red-and-white checkered diner table, with a tipped-over glass salt shaker and a blurred diner interior in the background. Large text on the left reads, 'Our Mildest Horseradish Mustard' and 'Fresh Horseradish.

  • Want more fire?

    Same Recipe, More Heat.

    Mustard Up Spicy keeps the same horseradish bite and mustard warmth you love, then turns up the heat with Ghost, Scorpion and 7 Pot peppers for a burn that lingers. Same throwback flavor, a whole lot more kick.

    Try Mustard Up Spicy →
    A bottle of Jersey Girl Mustard Sauce stands centered on a red and silver tin canister on a diner-style table, with blurred red booths in the background.

  • Say, don’t forget your pal! 

    Gab a gift card 

    Starting at $10, it’s a fiery gift for spice lovers.

    Toss in a gift card

Mustard Up Mild FAQS

Everything you want to know about the mildest, most unexpected sauce in the Jersey Girl lineup. Horseradish bite, mustard seed warmth, and just enough heat to keep things interesting.

Mustard Up Mild uses a 4-pepper blend:

  • Jalapeño
  • Fresno
  • Habanero
  • Long Hot

The sauce base also includes horseradish root, mustard powder, turmeric, oven-roasted sweet potatoes, tomatoes, onions, garlic, lime juice, vinegar, water, black pepper and a touch of sugar. It’s naturally sodium-free, with no preservatives, gums or thickeners.

That’s exactly who it’s for. Mild heat, big flavor, and an easy first step into the Jersey Girl lineup.

We get it, salt makes things pop. That’s why we didn’t just pull it out and call it a day. Mustard Up Mild builds flavor from the ground up with oven-roasted sweet potatoes, horseradish root, mustard, turmeric, garlic, and lime, so every drop brings plenty of punch on its own. 

Shake it on your favorite salty snack, a hot dog, a pretzel, a plate of eggs, and it adds bite without piling on more sodium. You keep the salt where you want it and let the sauce bring the flavor.

Both. It pours like a hot sauce and eats like a mustard with a kick. Use it anywhere you’d reach for either one.

Regular horseradish mustard is mostly mustard seed, vinegar, and salt. Mustard Up Mild starts there and keeps going, with oven-roasted sweet potatoes, tomatoes, onions, garlic, lime, and a four-pepper blend that adds a gentle warmth regular mustard never brings. 

The result is a pourable sauce with more depth, a little heat, and none of the added salt. It does everything your horseradish mustard does on a hot dog or pretzel, then works on eggs, burgers, and roasted potatoes too.

Try these Flavored Sauces Similar Heat

A bottle of Jersey Girl Garlic Verde hot sauce displayed on a red and silver metal tin, set against a blurred retro diner background. Jersey Girl Garlic Verde hot sauce bottle shown on a rustic beige background with large product text, ingredient callouts, and a styled arrangement of garlic, lime, red pepper, tomatillo, onion, and herbs.
Garlic Verde Hot Sauce, Tomatillo, Cilantro, Lime & Mild 5oz
From $11.99
From $11.99
A bottle of Jersey Garlic Smokeless Hot Sauce stands on a red and silver metal tin in a blurred diner setting. The bottle has a brown neck sleeve with gold garlic illustrations and a white label featuring a hot dog illustration and the brand name 'Jersey Garlic'. A bottle of Jersey Girl Smokin' Chipotle hot sauce displayed on a rustic wooden table with food props like tomatoes, garlic, chili peppers, and a sweet potato. The left side features a large text panel detailing the flavor profile (chipotle, honey, maple) and product benefits.
Smokin’ Chipotle Hot Sauce – Sweet, Smoky & Mild 5oz
From $11.99
From $11.99
A bottle of Jersey Girl Hot Sauce stands upright on a red and silver tin container on a diner table, with a blurred retro diner interior in the background. A vintage-style promotional sign for Bee Sweet Mild Honey Hot Sauce, featuring a bottle of the sauce on the right and marketing text and ingredient imagery on the left. The sign has a distressed beige background with red and brown typography and shows honey, a sweet potato, jalapeños, garlic, onions, and tomatoes.
Bee Sweet, Jalapeño Honey Hot Sauce Mild 5oz
From $9.99
From $9.99

Contact US Or Leave Feedback

Phone:

908-268-6414

Email:

sales@jerseygirlhotsauce.com

Socials

Drop us a comment

  • 5 stars: 4 (100%)
  • 4 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
K
Karen A. (United States)
I love this sauce and the chipolte sauce

I love this sauce and the chipolte sauce. I have kidney disease and am a vegan so I use these two sauces (one for lunch and one for dinner) that puts flavor in the protein pellets my husband makes for lunch and dinner. Even if I wasn't sick I would still have these sauces. I wish there was larger sizes.

A
Anonymous (United States)
Seriously amazing

Seriously amazing. So good and can't believe theres no sodium.

p
paul b. (United States)
Great Hot sauce with subtle hints of assorted peppers and spice

Great Hot sauce with subtle hints of assorted peppers and spice. This one is really nice and definitely a delicious blend of savory seasonings.

A
Amy C. (United States)
Thank you Jersey Girl for creating another great

Thank you Jersey Girl for creating another great hot sauce! Clean ingredients and no sodium should be on everyone’s shopping list!!